Comer Insurance Agency
  • Home
  • Make a Payment
  • Request a Free Quote
  • Insurance
    • Auto
    • Homeowners
    • Farm
    • Life
    • Business
  • About Us
    • Referrals
    • Employee Directory
    • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Make a Payment
  • Request a Free Quote
  • Insurance
    • Auto
    • Homeowners
    • Farm
    • Life
    • Business
  • About Us
    • Referrals
    • Employee Directory
    • Contact Us

Make a Payment or File a Claim Online

We offer many ways for you to pay your payment with all of our companies.  Our customers are more than welcome to pay bills in person in our office or over the phone at (937) 585-4251 using your credit card or checking account at no extra cost.

Below are links that you can use to make payments, access your policy, and retrieve claim information. If you experience any issues making a claim or paying a bill, please call (937) 585-4251 and let us assist you!
​
Grange Insurance bill pay
Claims / Pay Bill
​

Auto-Owners Insurance logo
Claims / Pay Bill
​

Motorists Mutual Insurance logo
Claims / Pay Bill
​

Ohio Mutual Insurance online bill pay
Claims / Pay Bill
​

Progressive insurance
Claims / Pay Bill
​

Foremost Insurance logo
Claims / Pay Bill​
​
Comer Insurance Agency, Inc.
Phone Number:
 (937) 585-4251
Fax Number: (937) 585-6491
Email
111 South Main Street 
P.O. Box 579

DeGraff, OH 43318 
Office Hours
Mon, Tue, Thu, Fri: 8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Wed: 8:30 AM - 12:00 PM
Sat: 9:00 AM - 12:00 PM
Sun: Closed
Evenings by Appointment
Comer Insurance Agency, Inc.
Website by Berry Digital Solutions, LLC
​
West Liberty, Ohio